The Most Reliable 10-Year-Old Used Cars: Which Cars Last a Lifetime?

Nothing beats a brand-new car, especially when it comes with a multi-year warranty and an odometer reading of zero miles. However, with new car prices rising, many buyers are turning to the used car market.

But which used cars are the safest bets? A study by Warrantywise from last year provides the answer, showcasing the most reliable four-wheeled options available.

When shopping for a used car, reliability and durability should be key factors in making the right choice. The following list considers these essential qualities.

Evaluation Criteria

The rankings take into account:

• Manufacturer warranty coverage

• Cost of repairs

• Frequency of repairs

• Odometer readings

• Vehicle age

• Engine reliability

The rating system is based on claims made by drivers over the last ten years of a model's lifespan. Warrantywise's list features the most reliable models currently available, all meeting the same reliability standards. The selection applies to cars that are ten years old and have about 75,000 miles (120,000 km) on the odometer.

The data is based on an analysis from the past three years, identifying the most reliable used cars of the past year. The highest possible score is 100.

10. Kia Rio - Score: 82.1

The Kia Rio is one of the most affordable and reliable used cars on the market. With low repair costs and a dependable engine, it’s a great option for those looking for an economical and worry-free vehicle.

9. Peugeot 107 - Score: 83.4

The only European model on the list, the Peugeot 107, was developed in collaboration with Toyota. It shares its engine and mechanical components with the Toyota Aygo, ensuring high reliability.

8. Honda CR-V - Score: 83.4

The Honda CR-V is one of the few SUVs on the list. Known for its durable engine and well-built interior, the CR-V remains one of the best options for those looking for a larger, more practical vehicle.

7. Kia Cee'd - Score: 84.6

Another solid entry from Kia, the Cee’d combines a spacious cabin with reliable performance. Its well-built engine and low maintenance costs make it a dependable family car.

6. Toyota Hilux - Score: 85.3

The Toyota Hilux is legendary for its toughness and reliability. This pickup truck is a great choice for those needing a workhorse that can handle tough conditions.

5. Toyota Aygo - Score: 85.3

Sharing its platform with the Peugeot 107, the Toyota Aygo is one of the most reliable compact city cars. Its simple design and low maintenance costs make it an attractive option for urban drivers.

4. Toyota Auris - Score: 85.9

The Toyota Auris combines comfort, fuel efficiency, and long-term reliability. It has proven to be a durable option and remains popular on the used car market.

3. Mazda2 - Score: 85.9

The Mazda2 features a lightweight yet solid design, making it an efficient and reliable vehicle. With strong engine performance and a proven track record, it ranks among the best compact cars.

2. Suzuki Swift - Score: 87.9

The Suzuki Swift is well-known for its compact size, excellent fuel efficiency, and reliable mechanics. With one of the highest reliability scores, it remains a top pick among small cars.

1. Toyota Yaris - Score: 89

According to Warrantywise, the Toyota Yaris is the best-used car you can buy this year. Its highly reliable engine, low running costs, and durability earn it the top spot on the list of the most reliable 10-year-old vehicles.

As most people have probably noticed, Japanese cars dominate the list. Toyota appears with four models, while its subsidiary brand, Lexus, also makes the list. In addition, Honda, Mazda, and Suzuki are also featured.